Chateau Carbonnieux rouge 2015

- 94 Punkte WINE ENTHUSIAST, Roger Voss: "The firm tannins in this wine are dense and concentrated, ripe rather than dry. The fruit and juicy acidity give the wine richness and crispness at the same time. It has a great future. Drink from 2025."

- 93 Punkte VINOUS, Antonio Galloni: "The 2015 Carbonnieux is impressive. Dense and powerful in the glass, with layers of fruit and insistent, driving tannins, the 2015 has a lot to offer. Black cherry, smoke, scorched earth, licorice, cedar and game fuse together and all the elements are very nicely balanced in this impeccable Pessac-Léognan."

- 93 Punkte DECANTER, Jane Anson: "Attractive dark red fruits, subtle liquorice and gently insisting tannins. One that will deliver pleasure earlier than some. There’s a silky approachability, but it should also develop well.Drinking Window 2023 – 2035"

- 93 Punkte JAMES SUCKLING: "The dark berry and iodine aromas are fascinating with bark and black tea undertones. Medium to full body, juicy fruit and a savory finish. Hints of tobacco and chocolate. A long time favorite. Drink in 2020."

- 17,5 Pukte jancisrobinson.com, Julia Harding MW: “Deep crimson. Finest of tannins framing dark, elegant fruit. Complete and refined, subtle but with the promise of a long life. Savoury, rocky graphite finish. (JH)“

- 17 Punkte VINUM: „Hat nichts von seiner Frische und Fruchtigkeit verloren, hübsche Würze, perfekt proportioniert, beerig.“